Opinionista
Brendah Nyakudya
To My President, Robert Mugabe

Dear Robert,
Through the insanity that has been your reign there have been times when I seriously started to believe you were immortal and would live forever, but just recently your sister died and now I hear you are slowly losing your battle against cancer. It would seem all men die sometime.

It’s with this in mind that I felt the need to write this letter and say things that have been on my heart for a while, but never had a chance to say. People fail to understand my underlying loyalty to you which has often been seen as some insane allegiance to what they perceive to be a monster or likened to the warped sense of loyalty of a child to an alcoholic and abusive father.  I hope from this piece they will see what I saw and get a glimpse of what I feel.

First of all, I want to say thank you. It was because of your efforts that I was born into a country that was indeed free and embodied the very traits of the rainbow nation that South Africa seeks to be today.  I have freely enjoyed and taken advantage of the first fruits of liberation that you fought to give every person that called themselves Zimbabwean, regardless of their race. Post-war healthcare made tremendous advances and black and white sincerely lived side by side in harmony without the need for constant reminding to play nicely.  We had the luxury of living in a country where we felt safe at all times and petty theft was the extent of our crime worries.  There is a reason why the majority of displaced Zimbabweans would go back home in a heartbeat should things become tenable again and for this I thank you.  It was because of the Zimbabwe you built for us.

Thank you for emphasizing the importance of and giving so many resources to education. When you observe countries with a lack of it you truly understand the desperate need for it. Because of your belief in the need for every child to have education of the highest standard, we proudly grew up to be the country with the highest literacy on the continent. We are not who we are by chance, it was because of your high standards that we developed a work ethic that appreciates the need to labour hard to achieve one’s goals and this has held us in good stead when we had to survive in countries far from home, it’s given us an advantage over others because we get things done.  You never gave us BEE on a plate, thereby ensuring a culture of entitlement never crept in.

While I am grateful for what you did for us, there is a part of me that feels extremely angry and betrayed by you. At some point things went very wrong, and I believe it all began when Sally died. In your grief you forgot that, though you lost a wife, we had also lost a mother. You withdrew, became angry and turned your back on us. This rage was further fuelled by what you perceived to be treachery by the Blair administration with regards to the land reform programme and Britain’s refusal to fund it. Your obsession in righting this wrong destroyed us. While I understand and fully appreciate the principles behind your land reform policies, the fact that they were fuelled by fury made it a total shambles. You didn’t even see what was happening around you.  You were so caught up in this one personal vendetta, you single-handedly nearly ruined my future and the future of all the other millions of Zimbabweans that now have to live as second-class citizens in places so far from home in an attempt to feed their families. You stood by, watched us pack and go, all the while calling us names, but never once initiating dialogue to find out why we were leaving.

Do you have any idea how bad it’s become for those of us not fortunate enough to land on our feet? The pathetic lows we have had to sink to - from crime to prostitution - just to put food on our tables, qualified teachers and nurses having to settle for being maids and security guards.  You built us up only to let us be torn down and persecuted daily just for being foreign; with some of us having to die for it. You allowed the world to strip us of our dignity while you turned a blind eye as we became the laughing stock of the world. You betrayed us by standing by and allowing greedy ministers in your cabinet to literally rape our country for their own gain, leaving nothing for anyone else. Hungry children resorted to eating bark from trees just to survive while “she-devil-we-do-not-speak-of-who-you-married-in-a-moment-of-insanity” shopped up a storm around the world.

Not once did you ever stop to acknowledge or try to contain the imploding mess around you. There was never a time when you showed concern for us who have to inherit this mess that you created and are burdened with having to work twice as hard in an attempt to turn the country into anything worthwhile for our children to inherit.

You are dying now and the hyenas are baying at your door. As I see it, you have two options: You can either give in to the sharks and hand over the reins to the Mujuru’s/Shiri’s and plunge us into further darkness giving the world the right to remember you as a despot, or you can finally right the wrongs of the past years and handover to someone we can trust. It’s not too late and you owe it to us.  You owe it to me!  I am praying that in your final moments your heart is filled with remorse and that when you choose your successor, you take time to remember the Zimbabwe you always dreamed of, think of Sally and what she would have wanted and, please sir, just this one time, think of us. May your final gesture be of you finding a way to somehow start to give us back the country you have held to ransom for 15 years.

I will mourn deeply when you are gone and I will take time to remember the fond memories. But I will also keep the bad memories close at hand for one day soon I will be in a position to make change and I want to make sure I don’t make the same mistakes you did.

Until we meet again,

Brendah

More by Brendah Nyakudya




You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please login or sign up.
Mugabe was also our rallying point towards our freedom, i remember songs that we used to sign praising him and other leaders in the continent. Its unfortunate that he was allowed to destroy everything he fought for, I am disgusted by him and Zanu PF, the wanton destruction they presided upon will haunt Zim for many years to come. Just wish fellow South Africans take lessons and rise up to prevent the happenings north of Limpopo from happening to our country.
Mugabe the liberator died long ago. Mugabe the coloniser lives.
Dear Brendah, I would just like to say what an excellent read, and I think all of us South Africans and the entire world should read this. I don't live in my home country either anymore, but I Have posted this on my facebook profile, so hopefully my friends around the world do take up some time to read it. Thank you and keep up the brilliant work. Regards Tamelyn
Hi Tamelyn,
Can u please outline to me what real fascinated u on this article, its real exciting that you even posted it to your freinds on FB, THEN MAYBE THE TWO OF US can talk after that.. I have millions of evidences to prove that Mugabe was never a democrat for Zimbabwe, dating back from the death of Herbert Chitepo, Josiah Tongogara and so many Zanla cadres who were assassinated under the orders of Satan's incarnate Robert Mugabe.

Kindly Regards,

Yours Faithfully
Nhlanhla-the Muckracker.
Brendah
I totally fail to understand why you love this man so much. Mugabe has never been a democrat. Even in 1982 (two years into freedom), he was already making the case for a one party state. The use of the fifth brigade in Matabeleland and the side-lining of Joshua Nkomo, among many others were early examples of the tyrannical proclivities, with-which we are now fully familiar.

Im sure he wanted the best for Zimbabwe, and probably still does. But so do all tyrants and despots. Their love for their countries is subject to the condition that they rule, and they will gladly destroy the country they love to meet that condition. Politicians should be judged by their actions, not their intentions.

Mugabe is one of the worst examples of failed African leadership. Why must we Africans keep making excuses for these people? It's beyond me why we continue to lower the standards with-which we judge our leaders.

Wake up, Brendah! Africa needs intelligent people like you, but all that intelligence is wasted if you hold on to illogical beliefs like this.

(PS: Mugabe did not singlehandedly deliver freedom to Zimbabwe. It's part of the historically revisionist propaganda spread by former liberation movements to try and arrogate to themselves the role of sole liberator, and by implication, sole arbiter of truth and righteousness)
Malusi is absolutely correct to point out that victors write history. Mugabe was not the sole liberator of Zimbabwe from colonial rule.
As always, the picture is more complicated and dynamic; Mahmood Mamdani on the lessons from Zimbabwe: http://www.lrb.co.uk/v30/n23/mahmood-mamdani/lessons-of-zimbabwe
Brendah, Robert Mugabe has does done way more harm than good. He has raped and pillaged your country and you will still mourn his death deeply! It is this kind of thinking that has led to what Zimbabwe has become. Mugabe is a pig and I hope that he rots in hell for enternity.
Malusi, I appreciate your comment and your frustration but unless you only read the first part I do not believe my article made any excuses for him at all. He messed up I personally experienced it and cant deny it - he completely drove the country to destruction. But you say we should judge politicians by their actions which i did, but unlike the norm I acknowledged both good and bad. I think sometimes as humans we are so quick to point out the wrongs and never realise the good. You may not appreciate it or understand it but for me to be the "intelligent person" I am today is largely due to the efforts of that man and the environment he created for us to grow up in. Its easy to cry foul and judge the bad but may i never be so up my own arse that I fail to be thankful for what he did give me when I was growing up and the lessons I have learnt from him regardless of how it all ended up.

@Kerry its the age old mystery isn't it. Once you have been colonised, he who gives you the keys to your human dignity and freedom will always have a place in your heart. No matter how irrational that decision is. If you doubt that logic explain why the majority of South Africa will always vote for the ANC no matter what?
Brenda. You put too much faith in one man. Mugabe did not build the "excellent education system" in Zim, he perfected it...at least for a short while. Fact is the foundation was laid by the Rhodesians (especially the missionary schools). The legendary work ethic and "can do" spirit amongst Zimbabweans existed even before Mugabe took over in 1980. I would dare to say these admirable traits have even existed in SPITE of Mugabe.

While I appreciate your desire to balance the debate about his legacy, you are too kind...he did not "allow the world to strip us of our dignity"...he stripped Zimbabweans of their dignity. Please, at what point does the man assume responsibility? BEE may not be perfect, but at least its an effort to workout a solution to a complex problem. And what do you call the current ill-conceived and totally unsustainable "indigenisation" campaign going on if not unbridled entitlement. Instead of trotting out all the wonderful achievements Zimbabwe made, perhaps it is time for a more sober assessment of how the Zimbabwe project fell apart. Humility, I suspect will be an essential part of that process, for in it we will see our own roles in making Gods of humans. Mugabe achieved a lot physically in Zimbabwe, but he destroyed much more pyschologically. Killed a million dreams of children armed with good education, but who are now rejected like lepers the world over. What is the point of having a "key" when there is no "door to open".
A charming piece if a touch misguided. I lived through the transition from Rhodesia to Zimbabwe albeit as a child. A few misconceptions about Mugabe.

*That he implemented or expanded education in Zimbabwe - False he opened up what the Rhodesian government had built to all and maintained it badly. It has gone down hill since

* That he was ever a democrat or ever believed in Zimbabwe the Rainbow nation - False one word Gukurahundi

* That he was a freedom fighter or a liberator - Falsish he was involved yes but there is stong suspicion that those who truly led the struggle were sidelined or eliminated

* That he was ever interested in genuine land reform and the British scuppered him - Falce Britain pulled out of the deal when land started going to cronies and not to the people

* That Mugabe should be allowed dignity in death - Not by my estimation, he should be allowed the same amount of dignity of the tens of thousands that were buried in mass graves in Matabeleland and the thousands murdered for politial allegiance to the opposition since

This is The Mugabe situation... as I see it

www.hiltonmendelsohn.wordpress.com
www.twitter.com/hjmendelsohn
With all due respect, I am not sure the Zimbabwe you grew in Brendah was the same Zimbabwe I grew up in. You paint a very rosy picture of what was possibly the worst period of time for Zimbabwe.

The free and rainbow nation that you saw was never seen by most people. The Zimbabwe I grew up in was as racially segregated as pre Independence. The only difference was that it was no longer written into law. It is during the reign of Mugabe that we saw the biggest erosion of diversity in Zimbabwe. The Tonga people of western Zimbabwe’s culture and language virtually disappeared, the Venda people of south eastern Zimbabwe have seen their language wiped out and the Kalanga people of Plumtree areas have no hope for the survival of their ways. In comparison, South Africa has 11 official languages recognised in the constitution, now that’s a rainbow nation if you ask me. As for freedom, it is no coincidence that our government had a monopoly on all the media so our freedom to think objectively could be curtailed; as a result most of us thought we were free until we went to real free countries and discovered we were in fact brainwashed.

If you were unfortunate to come from rural Matebeleland, you would know that the roads predate 1980, all schools predate 1980 and all hospitals predate 1980. Whilst the rest of Zimbabwe was having schools and hospitals built, Matebeleland was facing food embargoes and no infrastructure development which has resulted in people in the region being berated for their lack of education, all of this done by a black government to other black people. You might also be aware that there was a genocide which was conveniently called a civil war against dissidents most of whose names, motives and backers remain unknown. All we are left with is mass graves full of men, women and children’s bodies which are there to see if you don’t believe it. Survivors bare scars of torture and missed opportunities under Robert Mugabe’s rule. In my view, this more than a petty crime.

Our indigenisation programme in Zimbabwe which is the closest comparison to BEE is fundamentally flawed in both its objectives and implementation. BEE involves the government helping black entrepreneurs through legislation and finance get a foothold into participating in the economy. In Zimbabwe, although the law has suggested buying into the ownership of privately white owned enterprises, the practical applications so far has been a smash and grab approach that we saw with the farm invasions which resulted in some ZANU officials having up to 3 farms each. This in my view is the culture of entitlement (kutora).

I respect your right to chose your hero and even deeper respect for you ability to defend him, but for the reasons aboveI find it hard to look beyond the mass graves, people’s scars, the greed, the continued looting of the country’s resources by foreign mining companies whilst we wave our certificates of Zimbabwean sponsored education which most us can not use in Zimbabwe.

Lindi Khabo
leekhabo@hotmail.com
Brendah,

I want to be brutally honest here. I may be wrong. From your name, you are of Shona extract. You are probably or have been associated, in one way or another, with ZANU elements. There was a time when you were on the gravy train but, lately, that train has delivered sour gravy and you want out. Is this a fair characterization?

Mfanyana
Brendah, am very saddened by your hero-worshipping of a bloody-thirsty despot
who brutally ended the lives and dreams of millions of pple. You may have benefitted from whatever he did for you and boast that the reason why you are "so intelligent" its because of his earlier policies, but i dont think you are that intelligent as you think. According to your article Mugabe lost his senses soon after the death of his wife, who you refer as your "mother", this could have been in 1992, the carnage and pain caused in Matebeleland from 1982 to '87 isnt worth mentioning bcze your dear Supreme Leader was empowering the great Shona pple at the expence of 2nd class citizens Ndebeles. Shame on you!
The Kidnapping, raping, killing and arrest of more than 30 000 innocent civillians are the hallmark and signs of a democrat as you said? Have ever heard about 2gallant ex-Zipra fighters Dumiso Dabengwa and Lookout Masuku, who falsely arrested then acquitted by the court of law only 4Mugabe to order thier rearrest, Masuku will later die in prison without enjoying the fruits of independence you yourself did enjoy. Brendah, i u real wanna be an "intelligent" and credible journalist try to broaden your scope and provide balanced facts cze what you are doing now is misleading thousands of ignorant Soutt africans who dont know our history. The reason why Geofrey Nyarota is now history in the world of journalism is bcze he failed to perform his duty to expose and report human rights abuses against innocent people in Mat province, he is now confined in the wrong side of history. Next time u talk abt your hero and your achievements, think of that child without a dad, mom, granny, think of those who never had the opportunities you are boasting of bcze of Mugabe's wicked policies.

Nhlanhla.
Thank you Brendah for your masterpiece on hero worshipping a Tyrant who has brought misery and hunger.A man whose hatred of the Ndebeles and other tribes is quite obvious.A man who precided over the death of 30 000 ndebeles and more than 300 opposition supporters in 2008 and he is your Hero.It's just the same as calling Satan a God.I dont blame you because most Shona people never believed that Gukuraundi realy took place because of the propaganda machinery during that time.The Shona people only learnt how monstrous and bloody -thirsty Mugabe was, when he turned his sword against them ,immediatly after the 2000 referundum and when MDC threatened his grip on power. More interesting to say is how the international community reacted when Mugabe unleashed his weaponry on the masses since 2000,SANCTIONS!! SANCTIONS!! but when the Ndebeles were being massacred the world gave a blind eye as if nothing happened !! Hero or no Hero Mugabe is worse than Idi Amin unfortunately he still with us and for years to come!!
Brendah please go to hell with your father Mugabe. What opotunities did he give us Zimbabwean in Matebeleland. Built a University with 99% of the students being Shona from all over Zimbabwe and 1% being from Matebeleland and the rest of Africa. What schools did he build in Mat'land, we had 3 A'level schools to service the western bulawayo province (Mpopoma, Mzilikazi and Luveve) all schools built during the so called imperialists (the ones your god father liberated us from). Yet Hre and the rest of Mashonaland enjoyed the fruits of the so called freedom those of us not shona enough had to live like 3rd class citizerns in our country. I remember the slogan back in the day that we the Ndebele should go back to South Africa now answer me this: Brendah Nyakudya what is your fine shona self doing here in SA leaving your darling hero Mugabe with his gorgeous country (rainbow country) that he won for you. Go to any city in Zim and count the whites, coloured, indians or Ndebeles you will be luck to get a handful. Daily Maverick please ban Brendah she is a ZANOID propaganda machine, SHE PROBABLY WORKS FOR THEM...