Opinionista
Sipho Hlongwane
Cope may be dead, but hope lives on

No amount of goodwill can sustain a weak side, and two different teams set out to prove exactly that last week. The first was the Stormers, Super 14 hopefuls who, despite the backing of an entire province of trendy fans, were soundly beaten by the Blue Bulls (curses be). The second one was that political black hole, the Congress of the People.

It was quite sweet actually, like watching a small child arm wrestling a grown man. The frantic exertions of the child may, at times, give the adult pause, but he knows he’s beaten even before his arm inevitably touches the table. The fight is really about salvaging as much pride as possible, from a hopeless situation. And so it was with the Stormers.

Sweetest of all, the Stormers had a ridiculous amount of support. They were all over the Interweb, even managing to score a trending topic on Twitter. I was very touched. But the Stormers didn’t stand a chance, not with all the hopeful, saccharine goodwill poured upon them by myriads of Capetonians. I was reminded a bit of that other doomed vessel of hope and belief, the ill-named Cope.

At least the Stormers didn’t sabotage themselves, and the dreams of thousands, by fighting each other. Cope’s end (let’s just face it – they’re done), the elective conference that became a policy conference that reverted back to an elective conference, the broken chairs, the fisticuffs, the court interdict, the vote of no confidence, all signalled the death of the best shot we had, in recent times, for a truly representative opposition party in South Africa.

You’ve got to hand it to Lekota – it takes something special to fall out with two political parties in quick succession. He must be the starkest example of that old saying: What goes around comes around. I wonder if Zuma or Mantashe indulged their weaker sides and called Lekota just to mock. I know I would have, had I been in their respective positions.

The hopes of thousands of young South Africans lie in sad ruins. These are South Africans who realised that the ANC had abandoned its roots, and had become hijacked by the corrupt and the tenderpreneurs, and had hoped to find a home where the vision of 1994 could be kept alive. I know, because I too was one of these young South Africans. I made my neat little cross next to Mosiuoa Lekota’s shiny face on the ballot paper.

Oh, how foolish I was. How foolish we all were. My first vote gave me a lesson I shan’t forget in a hurry.

Cope now having thoroughly collapsed upon itself, or rent itself asunder, we hopefuls once again find ourselves faced with the Sisyphean task of choosing another political party for which to vote. It is really like being asked to pick something out of a Tata catalogue – there’s not much to choose from, and none of it makes your heart race.

I am sure the Stephen Grooteses and Justice Malalas among us will offer damning analyses of why Cope failed, and though it will be swell and we’ll tsk-tsk at how terrible it all is, it still doesn’t offer solace to those who want something better for their country. Isn’t it about time someone founded a truly post-apartheid party in South Africa? A party based on principles of true non-racialism, non-bourgeoisie-exclusive opposition. A party that, while recognising the problems bequeathed to us by our troubled past, has the immediate and future needs of the people at heart. A party that will truly have the poorest of the poor at heart, and not pay lip-service to that notion. One that will not seek to protect narrow, minority interests, but one that will realise that to benefit the disenfranchised is to benefit all South Africans.

Is it too early for people who didn’t grow up under the burden of apartheid to start new political parties? Is that the problem? Is my generation still too young?

Cope may be dead, but the spirit of hope still lives on in our hearts. And when the time is right, we will act.

More by Sipho Hlongwane




You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please login or sign up.
There is one party that has proven itself a viable alternative to the ANC - come visit the Western Cape sometime. I'm not sure why a new political entity must be conceived in order for all young South Africans to get behind it? Surely the policy content & it's successful application should be of primary concern...not the shiny, new-car-smell?
Joseph - there isn't anything else at this stage but Zille hasn't always performed well lately. Her all male cabinet was unacceptable and the fact that she hasn't done anything about these darn toilets is irritating, at best.
She went through a stage of being very abrasive and annoying .... I see results in WC - sure; but she's becoming slow to react to important things - if ANCYL wants to make the province ungovernable because they're bored or jealous, she should do something about it, for goodness sake.
Hey Sipho, you captured my sentiments about Cope exactly (pity about the Stormers!). Looking at the DA's recent convincing wins in the by-elections in the Western Cape, isn't it time that good leaders (like some of those in Cope) join the DA, serve it humbly under its current leadership and grow into and with the party to become a credible opposition? We need to accept that all political parties are flawed and perhaps, just perhaps, the DA is the best vehicle we have to work with at the moment.
Dave, I have my criticisms of the DA. I wrote an entire column about it:

http://www.thedailymaverick.co.za/opinionista/2010-04-19-can-a-real-opposition-please-stand-up
Sipho, it is always painful to see a person lose their innocence. Those who have been around the block a bit may want to say, 'I told you so'. But this is polite company......and so nothing will be said.

If you hear the stories coming out of the Western Cape where the so-called alternative to the ANC rules, it leaves me in no doubt that politics is indeed a dirty game. The mistake that people make is making as there honesty, honour and integrity can EVER be spoken in the same sentence as politics.

Your first lesson in love has been delivered. Now that you are no longer a virgin, you'll be more circumspect and realise that they are all pretty much the same. It just the colours of their flags that are different but inside they are all the same.
Sadly, Sipho, it's not just young people looking for some hope in politics and political parties. There are many of us out there who are disillusioned with the ANC, can't vote DA due to its history, can't COPE and not happy with ID. Not sure where we're supposed to go! Desperately awaiting a decent opposition.
Nail on head Glenda. If we had an election tomorrow I really have zero idea who I would put my X next to.
Oh Bonginkosi, never a truer word spoken! Politicians are all the same, no matter the flag, no matter the skin colour, no matter the country. They are in politics for themselves, for their ego's, the shiny car etc.
If only the public at large got that concept things would change.
But ever naive, no matter what side of the fence we sit on, we all want to believe what we are being told (mostly anyway).
I had a good chuckle listening to one of the British Labour ministers in an interview just after the Labour party had lost some 90 or so seats - he proclaimed it a victory - and no doubt there were some voters out there who believed him.
I have yet to find the kind of political party you dream of - I would be right behind you in a flash.
I, too, voted for Cope.
I, too, was hopeful.
I, too, was sadly mistaken.
I agree with Russel - there is no such thing as an honest politician and I guess we all know but don't want to believe. Plato had the right idea and maybe one day we'll even consider a Soros type open society but for now we need to think of our children and vote for whomever sees to it that the country functions. I don't care about the skin colour or the history any more. I only want results and I'd really, really like it if those in power can end this culture of theft and corruption. I'm sick and tired of having my Euro friends and family rolling their eyes when they speak of governance African style and I'm sick and tired of egotistical, greedy, dishonest, ignorant (really, really ignorant)and uneducated people governing us. It's insulting.
@JacobaB & SiphoH: As South Africans that have the ability to make a difference (not just at the ballot box) I don't see why you're not able to support the DA as a viable alternative to the ANC.

I agree that no political party is perfect and realistically none ever will be. But what does that mean for us?

A) Sit on the fence and moan about the lack of a perfect, new/tabula rasa political party to support
B) Start your own new party (COPE has shown how difficult that is)
C) Find a party that has the best policy content & successful implementation record (bearing in mind that no party will ever be perfect), versus that of the ANC, and put your full support behind it

That's how I see it anyway...any further suggestions are always welcome :-)


Well, Cope has certainly shown what not to do as a break away party. It seems that the reality is that the DA will not in the long term attract ANC supporters, perhaps because we are only a few years post Apartheid. Numerically, any party must attract these people, none are in substantial numbers, so this learning experience needs to be taken into account if a new party is to form.