DM168

PLANT POACHING CRISIS

B(l)ooming ecological crime ravaging SA exposed after three Saudi Arabians caught stealing 1.6m seeds and flora

B(l)ooming ecological crime ravaging SA exposed after three Saudi Arabians caught stealing 1.6m seeds and flora
The police’s Springbok stock theft and endangered species unit confiscated more than 5,500 conophytum plants in February this year. (Photo: Ashraf Hendricks / GroundUp)

The case is yet another matter pointing to a time-sensitive crime crisis ravaging critical ecosystems in South Africa. Prosecuting authorities have warned that criminals targeting plants pose an immense and potentially irreversible problem. Some plants, like succulents, that are stolen and retrieved by police cannot simply be returned to the wild.

In October, three individuals from Saudi Arabia – a Ministry of Islamic Affairs employee, a financial analyst and a former soldier – touched down in South Africa. Within less than a month, all three were convicts in this country, where they had illegally picked more than 1.63 million seeds and flora items from areas around the west coast. The trio – Bedah Abdulrahman Albedah, Mohand Abulnaser Althenaian and his father Abdulnaser Mohammed Althenaian – were caught and pleaded guilty to related crimes.

Seeds stolen for export

It was suspected that they planned to “export” the seeds to a farm in Saudi Arabia. Instead of this plan proceeding smoothly, the trio arrived in South Africa, became the centre of legal proceedings, were forced to pay a R2-million fine and agreed to leave this country.

They did so as criminals. The action played out against them in South Africa in October, the same month that President Cyril Ramaphosa and several Cabinet ministers visited the convicted trio’s home country, Saudi Arabia.

According to a Presidency statement, during Ramaphosa’s state visit there, “discussions would focus on export market opportunities for South African produce and on South Africa as an investment destination”. This is ironic, given suspicions that the Saudi three wanted to smuggle stolen seeds from South Africa to their home country.

Flora and uncut diamonds

The case involving Albeda and the Althenaian duo is yet another matter pointing to a time-sensitive crime crisis ravaging critical ecosystems in South Africa. Prosecuting authorities have warned that criminals targeting plants pose an immense and potentially irreversible problem. Some plants, like succulents, that are stolen and retrieved by police cannot simply be returned to the wild.

DM168 has previously reported that if it is known where a plant was stolen from, and if conditions are suitable, it can be replanted using special techniques, only if security in that area was ensured.

At the end of October, in another crackdown on plant crimes, West Coast police were tipped off about a Ford Fiesta travelling from the Western Cape town of Clanwilliam with indigenous plants being smuggled in it. The vehicle was stopped in another Western Cape town, Citrusdal, and 3,491 plants were found. Four men were arrested for illegally having the flora.

In August, in another crackdown near Clanwilliam, a vehicle was stopped and searched – plants worth R400,000 plus five uncut diamonds were discovered in an occupant’s luggage. The occupant, who had no permit for the plants, was arrested.

Near extinction

Earlier this year, DM168 reported that plant poachers, including fugitives, repeat offenders and crooks who operate internationally, were probably behind the near extinction of some rare succulent species as they continued stealing hundreds of thousands of them.

Poachers were targeting the Succulent Karoo Biome, which stretches from Lüderitz in Namibia, across South Africa’s west coast and into the Western Cape’s Little Karoo. It is one of only two arid hot spots in the world where several specific plant species are found.

South African National Biodiversity Institute spokesperson Nontsikelelo Mpulo told DM168 in April that, over three years, the amount of material confiscated in such crimes had increased by more than 250%.

“[It] is likely that over 1.5 million plants have been removed from the wild in the past three years,” she said.

“It is very likely that some species have already been poached to extinction in the wild because the number of confiscated poached plants being housed at secure locations for court cases often exceed[s] the previously estimated total wild population size.”


Visit Daily Maverick’s home page for more news, analysis and investigations


Drastic plant crime spike

Now Advocate Aradhana Heeramun, who prosecuted the Saudi Arabia-linked case, has warned that the crisis has escalated.

“Since the beginning of 2022, there has been a drastic spike [in] these offences,” she said. “The illegal trade in wild flora and fauna is one of the largest illegal activities in the world, along with the illegal drug trade, illegal weapons smuggling and human trafficking. It is essential to recognise that environmental crime, unlike many other forms of crime, is a time-critical issue. As our natural resources are finite, lack of action may have permanent consequences.”

Heeramun previously described the plant poaching crisis as “an ecological tragedy”.

DM168 understands that authorities are pushing for severe legal action to be taken against plant poachers. In the case involving the three individuals from Saudi Arabia, within less than a month after touching down in South Africa, they contributed to the plant crime crisis and were convicted.

(Photos: iStock, Eric / Flickr, Mitchell & Dawn / Flickr)

Trip planned around plant theft

According to information provided by the Western Cape’s National Prosecuting Authority, the trio said they arrived in South Africa on 7 October.

They hired a vehicle at Cape Town International Airport.

“The entire trip was planned with the specific purpose of searching for and acquiring flora,” the prosecuting authority information said. They chose to stay in locations known for flora. The trio later met four others who were set to work with them.

According to the prosecuting authority information: “The purpose of their visit was to export the flora to a farm in Saudi Arabia.

“After spending days acquiring the flora, they departed from the guesthouse where they were booked in.”

Western Cape police spokesperson Warrant Officer Joseph Swartbooi said that after a night in a guesthouse in the Northern Cape, they left and planned to head to Cape Town. But police officers in the Western Cape were tipped off about this.

“They spotted the suspicious vehicle on the N7 highway driving at a high speed near Bitterfontein,” Swartbooi said. Bitterfontein is a village on the west coast.

The car was searched while police officers and CapeNature officials questioned the men, who could all speak English. Witbooi said “a number of bags containing seeds” were confiscated.

Based on information that emerged in legal proceedings, a total of 1,633,386 flora items were seized – this included more than 900,000 plants known as Felicia.

CapeNature ranger Hilton Bocks checks plants in Knersvlakte Nature Reserve in the Western Cape, one of the richest and most diverse succulent regions in the world. (Photo: Ashraf Hendricks)

Guilty as charged

Not even a month after they touched down in South Africa, the three accused entered into a plea and sentencing agreement with the state on 1 November in the Vredendal Regional Court. Albedah and the Althenaian father and son claimed that the flora, which was found concealed in their luggage, belonged to them. This meant that criminal charges relating to flora against the four other individuals, whom they had roped in to work with them, were withdrawn.

The trio from Saudi Arabia pleaded guilty to money laundering, possessing flora without the necessary documentation and contravening a section of Nature Conservation Ordinance No 19 of 1974. They were each sentenced to an effective seven years in jail.

The sentences were suspended for five years on condition that they did not commit the same crimes in that period.

R2m fine for ‘inexcusable conduct’

Abdulnaser Althenaian and Albedah also had to pay R2-million to the Criminal Assets Recovery Account and Western Cape Nature Conservation Board. Of the accused, Heeramun said: “Their conduct is inexcusable. They are all educated individuals who earn a decent living and have families.

“Abdulnaser Mohammed Althenaian (50) served in military defence. His son, Mohand Abulnaser Althenaian (25), is a financial analyst and Bedah Abdulrahman Albedah (40) is employed in the Ministry of Islamic Affairs.” All three convicts undertook to leave South Africa within 48 hours.

There have been other cases that point to the international extent of plant poaching via this country.

Byungsu Kim, a succulent smuggler from South Korea, was previously convicted of related charges in both South Africa and the US. In January, he was sentenced in the US to two years in jail. Prior to that, in April 2020, US citizen Kalman Kaminar, who was linked to a nursery in Los Angeles, was sentenced in Cape Town to two years in jail for illegally having succulents. This sentence was suspended for five years.

‘We must act now’

Earlier this month, Director of Public Prosecutions in the Western Cape Nicolette Bell, reacting to the Saudi-linked case, said her office was trying to tackle the plant poaching crisis. She said the country’s biodiversity had to be protected.

Bell added: “South Africa has a national as well as an international obligation to address wildlife trafficking. This is due to several international multilateral environmental agreements, which oblige South Africa to conserve its natural resources and ensure that international trade in listed wildlife species does not threaten their survival in the wild.

“There is a duty upon all of us to act now to ensure that our environmental integrity is protected.”

 Why we should care

  • Some plant species have probably already been poached to extinction. In just three years, it is likely that more than 1.5 million plants were removed from the wild and, in a month this year, more than 1.6 million seeds were stolen from the west coast.
  • In 2018, the cumulative age of seized poached plants was at least 44,000 years.
  • The South African National Biodiversity Institute (Sanbi) says plant poaching causes soil disturbance, and this can “destroy delicate organic crusts that characterise the region”.
  • Sanbi further says that “losing any species from the environment affects all other species within the ecosystem and leads to ecosystem function deterioration”.
  • Certain areas where succulents grow attract tourists and, if these plants become extinct, it will mean fewer tourists.
  • This will harm the hospitality industry and lead to job losses. DM168

This story first appeared in our weekly Daily Maverick 168 newspaper, which is available countrywide for R25.

Gallery
Absa OBP

Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Willem Boshoff says:

    Poaching is a crisis on every level and harsher penalties need to be imposed. Currently its mostly fines and I’ll wager that it does not get paid in most cases. In Cape Town plant-poachers sell their wares openly on the streets and there’s absolutely zero consequence. The SAPs apathy in this regard is a major contributing factor as to why syndicates are destroying entire eco-systems.

  • Lesley Young says:

    Wot no Mesembrianthemums??? Lithops, Conophytums, Haworthias, Aloes, Gasterias, Argyrodermas etc etc. etc. The only succulent listed in the article is Cotyledon. I wonder if the ‘court experts’ would know how to recognise seed pods or even the plants themselves. As to the comment about not returning to the wild – just photograph the evidence and hand them immediately to the nearest plant nursery/ garden club / xerophyte grower to propagate and produce more seeds and plants to be returned to the locations.

    • Ed Rybicki says:

      They are talking about just that case: I have seen the nursery in Sendelingsdrift where they have to try to keep confiscated plants alive, and there are thousands of mesembs there. The experts that have to testify in court about these matters are very well versed in plant identification and horticulture – and most certainly do know seed pods and the plants. They also spend far more time in court than is compatible with doing their jobs – so I really wouldn’t be disparaging about them if I were you. The tragedy is that it is almost impossible to rehome the plants, given their often very exacting requirements for nutrients, water and light and the fact that the exact locations of where they were stolen from are often not known.

  • virginia crawford says:

    Why is the fine so low? R2m for 1.6 million plants and seeds is not even R1.50 each! The fines and penalties are manageable business expenses. So bigger times, mandatory prison sentences without parole and listing on an international register of undesirables. Drones and rewards paid to people reporting these crimes would help to slow down this destruction. I wonder what King Charles the environmentalist will say to CR at their next tea party.

  • Marianne McKay says:

    Excellent article on an important issue. Thank you.

  • Change is Good says:

    This could be an incredible opportunity to start nurseries in all the small towns around the area that is being hit the hardest. This could absorb a lot of unemployed youth. Western Cape and Northern Cape Provincial governments need to invest to create a plant industry like the Dutch flower industry. This is turn will create a passion amongst locals for preservation and much needed income. They can sell to the Saudi Arabians. If other countries want these plants, they will unfortunately get them in any way possible. Saudi Arabia is starting to develop and this will not stop, unless we involve the local population and create a massive industry to sell to the whole of the Middle East or any area that requires dry climate plants. Lets not miss this opportunity.

  • Sharon Eigenhuis says:

    Wonder what the sentence would be if a S African broke the law in Saudi Arabia. Don’t think that person would be able to pay a small fine and come back home immediately.

  • Katharine Ambrose says:

    Paltry fines and suspended sentences won’t help. If these plants are national heritage then the punishment should reflect national outrage

  • Leslie Stelfox says:

    Theft under Islamic law leads to the amputation of the thieving hand! Unless that’s all been changed over there! An eye for an eye, a hand for a handful of seeds!

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

home delivery

Say hello to DM168 home delivery

Get your favourite newspaper delivered to your doorstep every weekend.

Delivery is available in Gauteng, the Western Cape, KwaZulu-Natal, and the Eastern Cape.

Get DM168 delivered to your door

Subscribe to DM168 home delivery and get your favourite newspaper delivered every weekend.

Delivery is available in Gauteng, the Western Cape, KwaZulu-Natal, and the Eastern Cape.

Subscribe Now→

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options

Caryn Dolley Bundle

The Caryn Dolley Fan Bundle

Get Caryn Dolley's Clash of the Cartels, an unprecedented look at how global cartels move to and through South Africa, and To The Wolves, which showcases how South African gangs have infiltrated SAPS, for the discounted bundle price of R350, only at the Daily Maverick Shop.

Become a Maverick Insider

This could have been a paywall

On another site this would have been a paywall. Maverick Insider keeps our content free for all.

Become an Insider

Every seed of hope will one day sprout.

South African citizens throughout the country are standing up for our human rights. Stay informed, connected and inspired by our weekly FREE Maverick Citizen newsletter.